The problem is that Twitter fails miserably at actually providing a way to get the full picture of the conversations that I want to follow or participate in.
Everyday I see a several messages (either main posts or replies/retweets) that interest me, but each time I'm frustrated by the inability to see all the responses that make up the complete conversation. Imagine being at a party where a dozen people are standing in a circle discussing something. Now what if each person could only hear a fraction of what's being said?
...
I'd really like to be able to see all the responses to these questions. I think I'd both benefit from, as well as be able to contribute to each conversation.
Don't get me wrong, I love microblogging. I understand security concerns, privacy, trust, etc. I just highly prefer the parent/child threaded model where all responses to a post are visible under the main topic. For example, in Facebook I can read responses from everyone, even if I'm not friends with them.
Alan is right, it can take a lot of effort on the part of a user to pull together a complete discussion thread on Twitter. However, I'm not entirely convinced a threaded model would work for Twitter, beyond the most simplistic reply thread view in the Twitter Web interface.
Twitter works slightly differently from Facebook and most of the enterprise microblogging tools I've come across, which do support the threaded model. For example, baked-in support for likes, group and other filters. Still, Twitter is open enough that someone could create a threaded interface - and in fact many have tried. Other than the 140 character limit, this minimal structuring is probably a critical difference between Twitter and other tools.
I do also wonder if we are expecting too much from microblogging concept. Because of the structure they offer, I sometimes feel that non-Twitter microblogging tools turn into discussion forums that simply have a desktop widget and real-time notifications. When this happens, they lose the utility of microblogging. Rather than a criticism of the tools, I think this perhaps suggests that:
- There are times when we want a less transient discussion but lack access to an appropriate place to do it; and
- The way we integrate and link social objects across different social media channels still isn't good enough.
BTW Alan - I found your post via good old RSS.